觀點新型冠狀病毒

Why the Germans Do it Better by John Kampfner — paean to a nation

A highly readable historical account celebrates the achievements of a ‘grown-up country’

Germany’s proficient handling of coronavirus has made it the envy of much of Europe. Its consensual political culture, decentralised government, well-funded public services and mighty industrial base have all gained new lustre during the pandemic. Angela Merkel’s dispassion — decried as ponderousness, even complacency — has served the country well during a medical emergency. In April, a social media clip of the German chancellor’s pedagogical explanation of the meaning of the viral reproduction number became an instant hit. So John Kampfner’s book Why the Germans Do it Better is both well-timed and well-aimed.

Kampfner, a former foreign correspondent as well as a one-time editor at the New Statesman magazine, delivers a paean to postwar Germany and its extraordinary success. “It has established a new paradigm for stability that equivalent countries, such as the US, France and my own, the UK, are for different reasons struggling to achieve.” This he attributes to Germany’s “emotional maturity and solidity” born from the traumas of its 20th-century history, which contrasts favourably with the “make-it-up-as-you-go-along hubris of those in other countries who think they know better, but do not”. Unlike France or Britain, Germany cannot take refuge in past glories.

Langsam aber sicher. Slow but sure. It should be Merkel’s motto. But Kampfner contends that a “punctilious, deliberative approach” has been essential to Germany’s deft handling of four key points in its postwar history: economic reconstruction and the entrenching of democracy in a 1949 basic law or constitution; the protest movements of 1968; the fall of the Berlin Wall in 1989; and the migrant crisis of 2015.

您已閱讀33%(1693字),剩餘67%(3445字)包含更多重要資訊,訂閱以繼續探索完整內容,並享受更多專屬服務。
版權聲明:本文版權歸FT中文網所有,未經允許任何單位或個人不得轉載,複製或以任何其他方式使用本文全部或部分,侵權必究。
設置字型大小×
最小
較小
默認
較大
最大
分享×